In article <he8Le.1779$Ke3.207548@news1.epix.net>,
Matt Whiting <whiting.TakeThisOut@epix.net> wrote:
> If the original VW Beetle used the front
> wheels for driving with the rear engine, it wouldn't be able to move at
> all in the snow. Do you really not understand this concept of weight
> distribution?
OK here is what you said:
> It isn't a FWD or RWD issue, it is a weight distribution issue. If a
> car was perfectly balanced fore and aft, then RWD would perform as well
> as FWD starting out and would perform better once you were moving as you
> aren't asking the same set of wheels to both pull and steer. And the
> steeper the hill becomes, the more weight shifts to the rear and the
> better RWD becomes.
I certainly understand what you said and now I'm wondering why you even
bothered saying it.
What is perfect weight distribution? It varies with the specific
driving situation. I'm not talking "ifs" but reality from my
experiences.
I should say I liked my two VW beetles I had for 6 yrs, but they just
don't compare to my FWD experiences.
You are correct about RWD getting a weight shift increase when going up
hill, however a typical FWD front engine is still better than a RWD
front engine vehicle, due to it's initial weight forward bias.
For other normal driving conditions FWD front engine excels.
Note I'm not talking racing where both steering and driving the front
wheels is a negative.
I find I can go up a hill with FWD and all season tires that my RWD
front engine cars couldn't go up with winter tires; chains were required.
My FWD cars only bog down when deep snow drags underneath. The VW
beetle had the same problem, with the additional problem that it's front
bottom shape tended to toboggan it up off it's wheels in deep snow,
requiring the snow to be removed from underneath it, to get the driving
wheels back on the ground.
The RWD rear engine VW bug presented the problem of not enough weight
on the front wheels to steer and track well on slippery roads and even
on dry roads with a strong cross wind.
I'm speaking from the experience of 25 recent years of several different
Chrysler FWD cars, a significant size range from the '79 Horizon to the
'95 Concord, preceded by 14 years of RWD front engine and 6 years of two
RWD VW beetles.
Oh yes I also had a GMC stretch length Van, that I converted to a
camper, for 15 years. What a dandy it was in the snow! >
In all of those years winter conditions were several months of typical
Canadian snow and ice. The last 30 years included many drives on steep
hills to ski hills in the western Canadian mountains.
Being an engineer and a car buff, including doing much of my own
maintenance, I'm fully aware of what is happening to my vehicle as I
drive.
The Magnum in the subject we have above I wouldn't even attempt to use
in the winter driving I do. Why make winter driving more difficult?
>> Stay informed about: Magnum