GM Death Watch 180: Bail!
http://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/gm-death-watch-180-bail/
Detroit's not flying the white flag just yet, but you can hear the
unmistakable sounds of unfurling. Post Black Tuesday, GM CEO Rick
Wagoner set about painting General Motors as a victim of unforeseeable
circumstances; the switch from truck to car sales was faster than
"anyone" could imagine. Chrysler CEO Bob Nardelli simply said
everything's fine– a sure sign that nothing is. And earlier today, Ford
President Mark Fields pleaded for government intervention to
protect/create a domestic electric vehicle battery industry. Clearly,
finally, The Big 2.8 are thinking ahead. To government bailouts.
Chrysler will be the first to file for Chapter 11. Ironically, the
ailing automaker's also the least likely to receive government
assistance. Yes, the feds bailed out Bear Stearns. Yes, the U.S.
government provided Chrysler with hundreds of millions in loan
guarantees the last time ChryCo was up against the wall– and received
handsome rewards for Lee Iaccoca's rescue. But that was then. This is now.
Chrysler owners Cerberus don't want an auto company-shaped millstone
around their neck. Any pretense that the private equity firm bought
Chrysler to run as a going concern will disappear the day they file.
Cerberus will use C11 to break-up the company, sell what it can, sue
Daimler, settle out of court and run in the opposite direction. You want
federal subsidies/guarantees/loans/whatever to keep this sucker afloat?
YOU get ‘em.
No doubt Chrysler's new new owners will receive some kind of public
assistance. But the idea that the entire company can be saved will be
jettisoned by everyone except the unions– who'll take what they can get.
Even if the Chrysler's dissolution gives GM and Ford a dead cat bounce–
and frankly, who could tell in this market?– GM will crank-up its
lobbying efforts for government assistance. Massive hybrid tax credit
for the electric - gas Chevrolet Volt? It's a given. Credits for
"resurrecting" old factories will also reappear. In fact, all the
creativity that should have gone into GM's cars will flow into shaping a
massive, green-tinged begging bowl.
And then, catastrophe. All these bail-out band aids cannot staunch GM's
wounds. The company will have to file. At that point, the tax-funded
pity party will REALLY start.
While America doesn't need a nationalized automobile industry any more
than England did, there's no question GM will find a willing partner in
Washington. For one thing, bailing out Detroit will mean bailing out
Michigan. The state is [still] too large and too powerful to let sink
beneath the Great Lakes under the weight of a total GM failure– despite
massive complicity. For another, the political narrative is pretty
compelling. It's not just Detroit that's on its knees (so to speak),
it's AMERICA! Let's keep America rolling! (Again.)
Of course, the southern states, where the transplants frolic, will be
none too happy watching their patrons' profits attacked by
federally-subsidized domestic competition. So there will be conditions
placed on these subsidies/guarantees/loans/whatever. Lots and LOTS of
conditions.
The days of excessive trough snuffling (i.e. Rick Wagoner's $14.4m
annual pay packet) will be finished. Pay will finally be tied to
performance. Current management will get a bit of a tongue-lashing on
the Hill by the aforementioned southern reps, but the Powers that Were
will drift off on their golden parachutes with their money and yes,
pride, intact.
The unions will demand– and receive– job guarantees. The feds will
stipulate that none of the money provided can be spent building cars
overseas, including Mexico and Canada. While GM will sleaze this–
building overseas cars here, importing parts– this stricture will
condemn GM to complete oblivion. But hey, you can't fight the will of
the working man.
And if that's not enough to turn a mediocre car company into an entirely
non-competitive corporate entity, there will be enough embedded green
initiatives to plant a good-sized forest. The word "sustainable" will
echo through the loan agreement like a cannon fired in the Grand Canyon–
with about as much effect on the environment.
I'd like to think that a new GM will rise from the ashes of the old. But
it seems obvious to me that neither GM's custodians nor the feds will
have the foresight, courage or political will to do what really needs
doing: the breakup and sale of all GM's brands.
That strategy would "save" GM by destroying it. The talent locked-up
within GM would be freed from the stifling, overarching bureaucracy, to
emerge in a focused and streamlined fashion. But a life-saving break-up
would require a fundamental shift in public consciousness. A politically
incorrect recognition that the American free market cuts both ways;
helping the losers weakens the system, rather than improves it. You
can't create competitiveness through legislation any more than you can
outlaw it.
It's a lesson GM will learn soon enough, one way or the other.
--
Civis Romanus Sum