99 Legacy - turn signal noise (ignition OFF)

The car is parked, neither the flashers nor the turn signal switch is
activated, and the key is NOT in the ignition switch. It would make
random flasher or turn signal noises at uneven intervals and irregular
periods of time while driving, and for a short period (a few minutes)
after the car is turned-off & the ignition key is removed. I heard it
one time about 1 year ago, and then again this morning, and not
anytime in between since the last time. No maintenance was recently
done, and the flashers & turn signals work normally, and it's not
related to acceleration, turning, braking etc. but is completely
random. I drove the car 3 times today and only heard it in the AM. The
last time it was in the PM. I don't get it, but it's really hard to
fix intermittent problems. Anybody every heard of this?

===========================================
On 27 Sep 2006 08:59:23 -0700, "Dmitriy" <dvmartyn.RemoveThis@oakland.edu> wrote:
>
>newbie2@aohell.com wrote:
>> I have a 1999 Legacy L sedan 4dr (not Outback) which started making
>> turn signal or flasher noises (like the turn signal is actuated, but
>> the ignition switch is OFF and the car is in park).
>>
>> Anyone ever heard of this, or know the fix or workaround?
>
>So wait... when it makes that noise, is a turn signal turned on? Or is
>the car just sitting there with EVERYTHING turned off?
 >> Stay informed about: 99 Legacy - turn signal noise (ignition OFF) 

- Where is the noise coming from? Does it sound like its coming from
inside the dashboard, or from the engine bay?

- Is it clicking that is identical to the flasher sound, or just
clicking?

If it's identical to the flasher sound... it's probably some sort of
relay, maybe there is a short somewhere... hard to tell.

If it's just clicking, it might be just your engine cooling
down/heating up (metal expanding/contracting), but you probably
wouldn't hear it while you're driving.


newbie2 DeleteThis @aohell.com wrote:
> The car is parked, neither the flashers nor the turn signal switch is
> activated, and the key is NOT in the ignition switch. It would make
> random flasher or turn signal noises at uneven intervals and irregular
> periods of time while driving, and for a short period (a few minutes)
> after the car is turned-off & the ignition key is removed. I heard it
> one time about 1 year ago, and then again this morning, and not
> anytime in between since the last time. No maintenance was recently
> done, and the flashers & turn signals work normally, and it's not
> related to acceleration, turning, braking etc. but is completely
> random. I drove the car 3 times today and only heard it in the AM. The
> last time it was in the PM. I don't get it, but it's really hard to
> fix intermittent problems. Anybody every heard of this?
>
> ===========================================
> On 27 Sep 2006 08:59:23 -0700, "Dmitriy" <dvmartyn DeleteThis @oakland.edu> wrote:
> >
> >newbie2@aohell.com wrote:
> >> I have a 1999 Legacy L sedan 4dr (not Outback) which started making
> >> turn signal or flasher noises (like the turn signal is actuated, but
> >> the ignition switch is OFF and the car is in park).
> >>
> >> Anyone ever heard of this, or know the fix or workaround?
> >
> >So wait... when it makes that noise, is a turn signal turned on? Or is
> >the car just sitting there with EVERYTHING turned off?
 >> Stay informed about: 99 Legacy - turn signal noise (ignition OFF) 

In article <tr5mh2dbodqot951ra2roclcee4mfkcfft@
4ax.com>, aaa.RemoveThis@bbb.com says...
> The car is parked, neither the flashers nor the turn signal switch is
> activated, and the key is NOT in the ignition switch. It would make
> random flasher or turn signal noises at uneven intervals and irregular
> periods of time while driving, and for a short period (a few minutes)
> after the car is turned-off & the ignition key is removed.

Might be an under-dash relay clicking on and off.

Any problems with your battery running flat?

Any problem at all, that occurs when it's doing
this?

If not...and you've noticed it over several
years...sounds like something you can just leave
be.
 >> Stay informed about: 99 Legacy - turn signal noise (ignition OFF) 

On Thu, 28 Sep 2006 15:16:11 GMT, CompUser <NoooSpamm.TakeThisOut@yahoo.com>
wrote:

>In article <tr5mh2dbodqot951ra2roclcee4mfkcfft@
>4ax.com>, aaa.TakeThisOut@bbb.com says...
>> The car is parked, neither the flashers nor the turn signal switch is
>> activated, and the key is NOT in the ignition switch. It would make
>> random flasher or turn signal noises at uneven intervals and irregular
>> periods of time while driving, and for a short period (a few minutes)
>> after the car is turned-off & the ignition key is removed.
>
>Might be an under-dash relay clicking on and off.
THAT SOUNDS LIKE A VERY PLAUSIBLE POSSIBILITY

>
>Any problems with your battery running flat?
>
NOPE... BRAND NEW ALTERNATOR TOO.

>Any problem at all, that occurs when it's doing
>this?
NOT THAT I CAN NOTICE, BUT IT HAPPENS SO SELDOM THAT I CAN'T REALLY
TELL IF ANYTHING IS DISABLED WHEN IT IS HAPPENING.

>
>If not...and you've noticed it over several
>years...sounds like something you can just leave
>be.
I WOULD LET IT BE, BUT IT'S THE CAR THAT MY WIFE DRIVES, AND SHE GETS
ALL FREAKED OUT WHEN IT HAPPENS.

THE PROBLEM WITH INTERMITTENT (UNKNOWN) TROUBLE IS THAT IT'S HARD TO
FIX SOMETHING WHEN IT NOT COMPLETELY BROKE. I JUST NEED TO WAIT UNTIL
IT HAPPENS AGAIN TO TRY TO ISOLATE IT.
 >> Stay informed about: 99 Legacy - turn signal noise (ignition OFF) 

On 28 Sep 2006 10:59:31 -0700, "Dmitriy" <dvmartyn DeleteThis @oakland.edu> wrote:

>- Where is the noise coming from? Does it sound like its coming from
>inside the dashboard, or from the engine bay?
THE DASHBOARD AREA, NOT THE ENGINE COMPARTMENT
>
>- Is it clicking that is identical to the flasher sound, or just
>clicking?
THE CLICKING SOUND IS IDENTICAL TO THE TURN SIGNAL OR FLASHER SOUNDS,
BUT NOT THE RYHYM & FREQUENCY OF THE FLASHER SOUND.
>
>If it's identical to the flasher sound... it's probably some sort of
>relay, maybe there is a short somewhere... hard to tell.
YEP.. I MIGHT CHANGE OUT THE FLASHERS AND SEE IF I STILL HAVE THE SAME
RECURRENCE.
>
>If it's just clicking, it might be just your engine cooling
>down/heating up (metal expanding/contracting), but you probably
>wouldn't hear it while you're driving.
IT'S DEFINITELY AN ELECTRICAL SYMPTOM/SOUND.

THE PROBLEM WITH INTERMITTENT (UNKNOWN) TROUBLE IS THAT IT'S HARD TO
FIX SOMETHING WHEN IT NOT COMPLETELY BROKE. I JUST NEED TO WAIT UNTIL
IT HAPPENS AGAIN TO TRY TO ISOLATE IT.
>
>
>newbie2@aohell.com wrote:
>> The car is parked, neither the flashers nor the turn signal switch is
>> activated, and the key is NOT in the ignition switch. It would make
>> random flasher or turn signal noises at uneven intervals and irregular
>> periods of time while driving, and for a short period (a few minutes)
>> after the car is turned-off & the ignition key is removed. I heard it
>> one time about 1 year ago, and then again this morning, and not
>> anytime in between since the last time. No maintenance was recently
>> done, and the flashers & turn signals work normally, and it's not
>> related to acceleration, turning, braking etc. but is completely
>> random. I drove the car 3 times today and only heard it in the AM. The
>> last time it was in the PM. I don't get it, but it's really hard to
>> fix intermittent problems. Anybody every heard of this?
>>
>> ===========================================
>> On 27 Sep 2006 08:59:23 -0700, "Dmitriy" <dvmartyn DeleteThis @oakland.edu> wrote:
>> >
>> >newbie2@aohell.com wrote:
>> >> I have a 1999 Legacy L sedan 4dr (not Outback) which started making
>> >> turn signal or flasher noises (like the turn signal is actuated, but
>> >> the ignition switch is OFF and the car is in park).
>> >>
>> >> Anyone ever heard of this, or know the fix or workaround?
>> >
>> >So wait... when it makes that noise, is a turn signal turned on? Or is
>> >the car just sitting there with EVERYTHING turned off?
 >> Stay informed about: 99 Legacy - turn signal noise (ignition OFF)